A few weeks ago I read a letter to the editor in The News Enterprise, an Elizabethtown KY newspaper (Hardin County) and of course serving many surrounding Kentucky communities and counties, by an esteemed gentlemen regarding the issue of the federal government intervening on Arizona’s immigration statute. In all fairness, a few things should be required before reading my abbreviated (space constraints imposed by newspaper) response.
First, a reading of the original editorial by Jim Wiese of Elizabethtown KY entitled “Who are the scofflaws?” should be in order. Second, though Mr. Wiese did not identify himself as such, indicating a personal view versus a stance on behalf of any organization affiliated with, many local residents know and identify him through his chairmanship of the Hardin County Republican Party, and he ended his opinion with a firm recommendation to elect “conservative” politicians in the upcoming November 2010 election. Thirdly, without respect to his political opinions, associations or affiliations, Mr. Wiese is locally infamous for his continual commitment to community, commonwealth, and country. Finally, I personally know Mr. Wiese: he is a member of the Staff Judge Advocate for the United States Recruiting Command (USAREC) at Fort Knox KY, where I served in the military as a Human Resources Specialist from 1997 – 2001, and as a government contractor working on the re-branding and transition of the Army into the cyberspace with GoArmy.com from 2001 to 2004; I have nothing but reverent memories of our limited encounters.
After painful editing of my original 634 word response, I settled on the below submission to the newspaper’s editorial board; not knowing what, if any, will appear in print, here is my final draft.
Clarifying Constitutional Confusion
I’m not a constitutional scholar but that doesn’t prevent me from taking a participatory role, or anyone from taking active roles to fuller understand the issues facing our common tranquility and security. I’m sure it was a mere matter of space allocation wherein Jim Wiese (Aug 1st “Who are the scofflaws”) was unable to explain clearly how federal government had no business in Arizona’s state law to handle the immigration problem as they saw fit.
Yes, we are individual states ‘contracted’ for a common goal (mainly defense) creating our United States of America, after deciding it was counter-productive and dangerous to go it alone; recognizing and accepting the fact that, at times, the needs of the whole must sometimes trump the desires of one. This is why states are forbid from entering into treaties and cannot pass laws counter-intuitive to the nation’s goals as a whole.
Does a state have the right to protect itself? Absolutely! They have every right to expect that when threatened, the collective United States will come to its aid. Does any state enjoy the right to circumvent federal statutes, going outside prescribed parameters of the law? No. Is Arizona really the litmus of American ideals we want to champion? They recognized and adopted the federal holiday honoring Martin Luther King, Jr. only when they couldn’t obtain a Super Bowl bid – when it became financially necessary, not morally acceptable or right. Is Kentucky that beacon for others to emulate, passing the 13th (KY rejected 2/24/1865) 14th (rejected 1/8/1867) and 15th (rejected 3/12/1869) Amendments on March 18, 1976?
America needs action, not knee-jerk reactions. America needs reasonable, equitably enforced immigration laws. We don’t need states running amuck, acting outside the prescribed (constitutional) guidelines. We have recognized, reacted, and corrected that behavior before – at the federal level – Brown v. Board of Education as a small example. Current calls for the repeal of the 14th Amendment are distasteful, disenfranchising, and a deliberate distraction.
An un-adjudicated charge of malfeasance doesn’t justify subverting federal law by individual states. WE, the American citizenry, are guilty of malfeasance; we fail to participate, we fail to vote, and it is we who keep sending to our hallowed capitol those more concerned about corporate campaign donations than the constituents they’re charged to serve. In November, we need common sense citizens regardless of political affiliation; who know what living on a budget means, can balance a checkbook, and appreciate the struggles of citizens, not corporate donors.
W. R. Mineo
Vine Grove KY
Update: 16 August 2010
The News Enterprise ran a nicely edited version of my editorial, enhancing it with the following cartoon as its lead:
Read the online, edited version at News Enterprise Opinion section for Aug 15, 2010


